Sample review form for Komunikaty Mazursko-Warmińskie

Title of the article:

Date:

Overall rating: (please insert an X)
The article can be published
in its current form [ ]
after minor corrections [ ]
after substantive changes [ ]
The article is not suitable for publication [ ]

Detailed rating:

Contents:
Yes/No/not present
1. Is the title clear and properly reflects the content of the article? [ ] [ ]
suggested change: ......................................................... ............................................................. .....
2. Has the article been previously published as a whole or in parts? [ ] [ ]
3. Does the work reflect/extend the current state of knowledge? [ ] [ ]
4. Is the literature on the subject appropriately selected and used? [ ] [ ]
5. Are the methods, interpretations and conclusions correct? [ ] [ ]

Style:
1. Is the article constructed well? [ ] [ ]
2. Is the text clear and linguistically correct? [ ] [ ]
3. Could the text be shortened without harm to its sense? In which places? [ ] [ ]
4. Is the illustrative material (figures, etc.) appropriately selected and developed? [ ] [ ] [ ]
5. Are the footnotes edited correctly? [ ] [ ]
6. Does the summary accurately reflect the main problems of the work? [ ] [ ]


Detailed notes:


Confidential comments to the editors:


Information for authors: